Kubernetes uses the Container Network Interface (CNI) to provide networking functionality to containers. Networking is implemented in CNI plugins. The interface / plugin model enables Kubernetes to support many networking options implemented via plugins such as Calico, Antrea, and Cilium.
Anyone may write a CNI-plugin. The expectation is the plugin will support specific operations defined in the specification (e.g. 0.4.0). These operations include:
ADD: Add a container to the network.
DEL: Delete a container from the network.
CHECK: Check whether the container’s network is as expected.
CNI Plugins are often only concerned with container to container networking. Kubernetes constructs such as services are still handled by kube-proxy. This means selecting a target pod for a service may still happen via IPtables (round-robin) on the host. Once the target pod is selected, the networking facilitated by the CNI plugin will pick up from there. Some plugins replace kube-proxy for their own alternative implementation. Cilium, for example, has replaced kube-proxy for an implementation using BPF.
Enforcement of network policy is contingent on your choice of plugin. Some plugins, such as Flannel, do not enforce policy at all. This means that adding network policy objects to your cluster will have no impact. Most plugins, however, do enforce policy. Policy can be set for both ingress traffic to pods and egress traffic from pods. Kubernetes has a policy API that plugins may choose to respect. Some plugins, such as Calico and Cilium offer extended APIs through Custom Resource Definitions (CRDs) that provide additional functionality. Kubernetes network policy is namespace scoped with no ability to apply cluster-wide policy. The only CNI-plugin that offers cluster-level policy is Calico’s GlobalNetworkPolicy CRD.
Choosing a CNI Plugin comes down to your network topology, desired container networking features, and understanding of different routing protocols. Plugins that can be used in Kubernetes have all sorts of routing features such as:
- BGP for route sharing
- Tunneling protocols (VXLAN, GRE, IP-in-IP, and more)
- Native routing (no encapsulation)
Popular Tooling and Approaches
Calico has been one of the predominant CNI-plugins since Kubernetes became popular. It supports a variety of routing modes including IP-in-IP, VXLAN, and Native (non-encapsulated). It even supports versatile routing options such as only encapsulating when crossing subnet boundaries. With Calico’s native-routing abilities, it does not need to incur encapsulation overhead. This means Calico can achieve near native network speeds.
BGP is used to distribute routes when running in IP-in-IP or native routing modes. BGP is a well known route sharing protocol that many enterprise networks are capable of peering with. This enables enterprises to integrate pod networks into their networking fabric, making pods routable. This capability unlocks a multitude of network topologies.
Network Policy support in Calico is arguably the strongest of all CNI plugins. Historically, the work Calico did with network policy influenced Kubernetes adoption of those constructs. For example, Calico implemented egress policy before the Kubernetes project did. Along with full support for Kubernetes network policy, Calico offers its own NetworkPolicy and GlobalNetworkPolicy CRDs. These network policies offer advanced features. The global policy enables administrators to apply cluster-wide policies. Calico also supports mixing both Kubernetes native policies and its own CRDs.
Calico is the most common CNI-plugin we have seen in deployments. Tigera, the creators of Calico, offer extended enterprise features and support. Additionally VMware offers break-fix Calico support for those with the appropriate support subscription. With the above in mind, Calico is generally our first choice for CNI-plugin.
- Diverse routing mode support.
- Integrates with the Kubernetes API server.
- No direct etcd access required.
- Native routing incurs minimal overhead.
- Supports cross-subnet only encapsulation.
- Uses native routing for all intra-subnet routing.
- BGP route sharing enables advanced topologies.
- Most capable network policy support.
- Includes Calico-specific GlobalNetworkPolicy.
- Break-fix support offered by VMware.
- External data store not required
- Uses Kubernetes API.
- Scales with typha.
- BGP might not be possible in your environment
- If so, Calico’s VXLAN mode does not use BGP.
Antrea provides container networking based on Open vSwitch. Using Open vSwitch, Antrea is capable of offering routing via VXLAN, Geneve, GRE, or STT encapsulation methods. Unlike Calico, Antrea can enforce networking rules inside Open vSwitch, which should provide more performant policy enforcement relative to IPtables.
Those familiar with Open vSwitch are likely to find Antrea a very compelling option. Since Antrea is still in pre-release, we don’t recommend it for production use cases at this time.
- Support many encapsulation protocols.
- Familiar to users of Open vSwitch.
- Performant network policy enforcement.
- Octant UI support.
- Break-fix support from VMware.
- Must have Open vSwitch kernel module.
NSX-T is an extremely capable network virtualization technology. It is used to facilitate networking in datacenters around the world. As such, it is very uncommon to see the NSX-T CNI plugin used unless an existing NSX-T deployment exists. Introducing a net new NSX-T deployment for a Kubernetes platform introduces a lot of operational overhead. It is also common for teams running Kubernetes on top of vSphere + NSX-T to run a different CNI-plugin (such as Calico or Flannel) on top of it.
With this in mind, we only recommend considering the NSX-T CNI plugin if there is an existing NSX-T deployment and a strong desire to integrate container networking with it directly.
- NSX-T is familiar to many VI Admins.
- NSX-T makes container networking feel more like normal VM networking.
- e.g. Namespaces are assigned their own subnets.
- Architecting, Deploying, and Operating NSX-T is a non-trivial task.
- It can be overkill for just container networking.
- Unlike most plugins, you’re not running the pod network on top of another.
- You’re instead using the existing network to run the pod network.
Cilium is a powerful CNI-plugin that uses BPF to make routing decisions in a highly performant manner. Cilium has replaced kube-proxy, which facilitates services, for it’s own eBPF implementation. This makes service routing decisions O(1) rather than the time complexity it takes to traverse many IPtables chain rules.
Cilium’s network policy enforcement also uses BPF. Calico leverages IPtables, which can have its own scalability issues and troubleshooting complexity. Overall, Cilium appears to be a very promising CNI in the Kubernetes ecosystem.
Cilium is new to the ecosystem and does not have as many production stories as we’d expect before recommending it. It may be worth considering for lab environments, depending on your tolerance for risk and comfort with BPF, or you may want to hold off a little longer.
- BPF enables extremely fast routing decisions.
- Network Policy
- Community support and enthusiasm is growing.
- Likely to become a predominant CNI-plugin.
- Need to ensure BPF kernel support.
- Sometimes not possible in highly regulated environments.
- Especially with older versions of RHEL.
- You cannot mix Cilium network policy with Kubernetes network policy.
- Newer player in the ecosystem, still experiencing paper cuts.
- CRD-based backend not scalable yet.