iPhone UI Automation tests: a decent start

July 20, 2010 Adam Milligan

Apple’s inclusion of the UI Automation component in Instruments with iOS 4 is a definite step in the right direction. It’s the first reasonable way to write tests that externally exercise your actual app, rather than weirdly injecting test code into it. It’s also the only way to programmatically test lifecycle issues, such as how your app behaves when put in the background, when rotated, when the device locks, etc. Good stuff. Unfortunately, the current implementation of UI Automation also has some significant problems:

  1. There’s no way to run tests from the command line. The subtitle of the WWDC talk for UI Automation was “find bugs while you sleep;” unfortunately, you can’t find bugs while you sleep if you have to wake up to click the “Run” button.
  2. There’s no way to set up or reset state. The lack of fixtures which set up a known state at the beginning of iPhone tests has been a problem for unit testing (with OCUnit, Cedar, or what have you), particularly for apps that use CoreData. Now it’s worse than ever, because UI Automation manipulates the actual state of the app on the device, much like Selenium does in a browser. Sadly, UI Automation provides no method for reseting the device’s state, making it nigh impossible to prevent tests from affecting one another.
  3. Part of the previous problem is that UI Automation has no concept of discrete tests; it provides no form of organization for your test scripts. No test methods, no set up or tear down methods, just one big stream of consciousness line of execution. Obviously you can break this up into functions as you see fit, but why reinvent the wheel? Since the test script is JavaScript, I like the idea of using Jasmine for this.
  4. There’s no way to programmatically retrieve the results of the test run. You could debate the value of solving this issue at the moment, considering there’s no way to programmatically start the tests either. However, even if you were to write some clever AppleScript to kick off the tests automatically the only indication of the pass/fail status is in the Instruments UI, so you still have to wake up to check the results. I searched around a bit for information on deconstructing the protocol that UI Automation uses to talk to the device, but I came up empty.

I’ll definitely use UI Automation, particularly for app lifecycle testing. But, not being able to add those tests to a CI build definitely stings. I very much hope Apple keeps their momentum for automated testing and makes it more developer-friendly.

About the Author


Problems with Photo tweets and more in version 1.8
Problems with Photo tweets and more in version 1.8

As you know, photo and video tweets are broken in version 1.8. The reason has to do with Twitter's new auth...

iPhone UI Automation tests with Jasmine
iPhone UI Automation tests with Jasmine

Since the language of the new iPhone UI Automation component is JavaScript I figured the easiest way to org...

SpringOne 2021

Register Now