ActiveRecord callbacks, autosave, before this and that, etc.

June 29, 2011 Danny Burkes

The Ugly Truth

On a recent project, we had an ActiveRecord model that declared some relationships and callbacks like so:

belongs_to :credit_card
before_create :build_credit_card

The intent was that build_credit_card would build the associated CreditCard instance, and ActiveRecord’s default :autosave feature on the belongs_to would save it.

What we discovered was that no CreditCard object was being persisted. We confirmed that :autosave is on by default for belongs_to relationships, so we couldn’t immediately understand why the new CreditCard wasn’t being created.

Googling proved futile, so we dove right in to the ActiveRecord source- and boy did we have a good laugh about 10 minutes later.

What we found was that the :autosave option works by simply declaring a before_save callback- that makes perfect sense.

In our case, however, we were building the object to be autosaved in a before_create callback, which ActiveRecords runs after the before_save callbacks (cf. the callback ordering docs).

So our first problem was that we needed to move the call to build_credit_card from a before_create callback to a before_save :on => :create callback.

Did you catch that? There is a difference between before_create and before_save :on => :create. A big difference.

While I understand the how and why of this, the semantics don’t make it obvious. So beware!

Now with our declarations changed to

belongs_to :credit_card
before_save :build_credit_card, :on => :create

We ran our tests again, and, still, no love. Ahhh, we’ve still got an ordering problem. In addition to the ordering semantics detailed in the docs, ActiveRecord also runs callbacks within a single group in the order in which they are declared. So, even though we changed the call to build_credit_card to occur in a before_save, it was still occurring after the :autosave before_save callback, because of the declaration order.

Finally, we changed our declarations to

before_save :build_credit_card, :on => :create
belongs_to :credit_card

and our tests were happy.


  • When using autosave with any ActiveRecord association, be very careful of callback ordering if you are building or modifying the inverse objects using ActiveRecord callbacks.

  • before_create isn’t ever the same thing as before_save :on => :create, even if it sounds like it should be.

About the Author

Danny Burkes

Danny Burkes is Senior Director of Asia Pacific, and Japan at Pivotal

Hyperic Brings Application Monitoring to Cloud Foundry
Hyperic Brings Application Monitoring to Cloud Foundry

Today the vFabric Hyperic team just announced plug-in support for CloudFoundry. Hyperic is an application ...

Android Tidbits 6/23/2011: Tabs and Colors
Android Tidbits 6/23/2011: Tabs and Colors

Pivotal Android Tabs We have published a simple Android project that illustrates how to use tabs in an And...

SpringOne 2021

Register Now